Why iPhone Live Voicemail must be off for ‘Rings you first’
Live Voicemail lets an iPhone answer your unanswered calls itself, so on Rings you first they never reach Cara until you turn it off once.
Last checked against the product on
You dialed the forwarding code, the app says your calls go to Cara, and then a customer calls and nothing arrives. No lead, no alert, no missed call for Cara to catch. If you're on an iPhone and you chose Rings you first, the most likely reason is a setting Apple turned on for you: Live Voicemail.
Turning it off takes about ten seconds, and you only do it once.
How it works
- Live Voicemail came with iOS 17. When a call rings out and you don't pick up, your iPhone answers it itself: it plays a greeting and types out what the caller is saying, live, on your screen.
- On Rings you first, your phone rings, and your carrier hands the call to Cara only when nobody picks up. That handoff is the carrier noticing that the call went unanswered.
- With Live Voicemail on, your iPhone picks up. The call was answered, so your carrier has nothing to forward, and it never reaches your ClearLine365 number. Cara never hears it.
- Nothing is wrong with your forwarding code or your carrier. The call simply stopped one step earlier than you expected.
Turn it off
- Open Settings on your iPhone.
- Tap Phone.
- Turn Live Voicemail off.

In short: Settings › Phone › Live Voicemail › off. Your forwarding code stays as it is, and you don't need to dial anything again.
This is an iPhone setting, so you change it on the iPhone itself. Nothing in the app or on the website can open that page for you, which is why both give you the path in words.
What to expect
- The next call you don't pick up rings out to your carrier instead of being answered by your phone, and Cara answers it. The lead shows up in the app and you get your usual alert.
- You keep ordinary voicemail. Turning off Live Voicemail stops your iPhone from answering and transcribing calls live; it doesn't remove your carrier's voicemail box.
- The card stays while Rings you first is your choice: under How Cara answers in the app, and in How calls reach Cara on the web. It's a reminder, not a switch: turning Live Voicemail off on the iPhone is the whole change. The first-time reminder on the Leads screen goes away for good once you tap Done, it’s off.
Limits
This only affects iPhones on iOS 17 and later, where the setting exists. Android phones have no Live Voicemail and nothing to turn off here. Pixel phones have a similar feature called Call Screen; a separate article will cover it.
Straight to Cara is not affected: your carrier hands every call over before your phone rings, so Live Voicemail never gets the chance to answer. You can leave the setting on, and the app says so under your choice.
Common questions
I use Straight to Cara. Do I need this?
No. With Straight to Cara your phone never rings, so there is nothing for Live Voicemail to answer. Leave it as it is.
Will I still see who called and what they wanted?
Yes, and in more detail than Live Voicemail gave you. Cara answers the call, asks what the job is, and writes it up as a lead with the caller's name, number, and what they need.
Do I have to turn it off on every phone?
Only on the phones your customers call that forward to Cara on Rings you first. A second cell that never rings for the business doesn't matter.
I turned it off and calls still aren't reaching Cara.
Check that forwarding is actually on for that line in Settings → Call Forwarding, and that your phone company is set correctly there — the code you dial is different for each one. If Silence Unknown Callers is on, that can also send calls somewhere you don't expect.